SONG: Rabbi David Block led the school in slow shira Oct. 29 as the school gathered on the floor of the gym to remember victims of the synagogue shooting in Pittsburgh. Earlier, students had lit 11 candles, one for each of the victims.

Carin Arbib

Psalms and slow singing soften a day of broken hearts after Pittsburgh shooting

November 1, 2018

Everyone had heard about how they died on the news. But on Monday morning, the Shalhevet community took time to appreciate the victims of the mass synagogue shooting in Pittsburgh as kedoshim — holy ones.

Last Saturday, the Jewish world was shocked as word spread of the shooting at the Tree of Life synagogue in Pittsburgh. A citywide vigil was held Sunday night in Westwood, as in other cities around the U.S.

Monday was the first day back at school.  Responding to the tragedy, first period classes were replaced by a schoolwide gathering in the gym at 8 a.m. Instead of sitting on chairs as at Town Hall, all 256 Shalhevet students sat on the floor to reflect and honor the 11 victims..

After starting off  talkative, the tightly bunched-up crowd became almost silent as speeches began. Many students wore blue, “to honor the memory of the victims, and stand together in solidarity against anti-semitism,” as requested by senior Kira Faerstein of the fashion club on Schoology the night before.

The ceremony started with a speech by Yoetzet Atara Segal emphasising hatmadah, perseverance.  Referring to news reports, she said that the victims were people who always came early to shul and were willing to help others,  and that all members of the Shalhevet community should follow their example. 

“Throughout the ceremony this morning,” Yoetzet Segal said, “as we reflect on what’s happening, let’s take into the rest of our days, let’s take into the rest of our lives this idea of constantly being there.”

Judaic Studies teacher Rabbi Abraham Lieberman spoke of the responsibility of everyone to improve the world.

“It starts literally b’einenu” — among ourselves — “how we deal with each other, how we deal with our family, how we deal with broken hearts and people who need help,” said Rabbi Lieberman.

As he was mentioning the connection between the week’s Torah portion — parshat Chayei Sarah, where Abraham buries Sarah — and the burial of the Saturday’s victims, he caught himself.

“We should try not to refer to them as victims,” said Rabbi Lieberman. “They’re kedoshim. They’re holy people. Any Jew no matter what stature… a Jew that is killed because they are a Jew, that is a kedosh.

Rabbi David Stein led the group in the recitation of tehillim (psalms) 20, 121 and 130, and students looked down at the sheets of text noting each word. 

Then Choirhawks gave a slow and restrained performance of Acheinu, which was followed by the whole room singing the song in unison.

Then, to honor each victim individually, juniors Gaby Lasry and Caroline Edry spoke the victims’ names as 11 students each lit a candle. The candles were moved into the foyer for the rest of the day for everyone to see.

Rabbi Block then led the room in a slow shira –slow songs sung in unison — beginning with a guitar-accompanied version of Matisyahu’s “One Day” —  quite different from the rousing Koolulam version of the song which was sung on the roof last year with drums, guitars and the whole school singing harmony.

Instead, Rabbi Block sat on the floor like the students, and simply played his guitar. The room sang all the words, including verses that had been left out last spring:

It’s not about win or lose

We all lose when they feed on the souls of the innocent

Blood drenched pavement

Keep on moving though the waters stay raging

The next song was “Esa Einai” — “I’ll lift my eyes to the mountains.”  With 11 candles flickering on the table behind them, it wasn’t quite as loud as the usual slow shira, either.  But it evoked the sadness and anger of the day, as well as the desire to rise stronger from the latest tragedy.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Meet the Writer
Photo of Jacob Joseph Lefkowitz Brooks
Jacob Joseph Lefkowitz Brooks, Editor-in-Chief

Some people have to discover their interests; others have no choice but to follow them. Jacob Joseph Lefkowitz Brooks has been a member of the Boiling Point staff since the first semester of his freshman year. He soon found a love for journalism and became the paper’s Arts & Culture editor the next semester, moving on to Features editor in his sophomore year, and Community Editor and becoming a member of the BP's Editorial Board his junior year. Jacob is now the paper’s Editor-in-Chief as well as director and creator of its forthcoming new magazine. Jacob is an avid moviegoer as well as a diehard fan of the Toronto Blue Jays and Raptors.

Leave a Comment

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.


The Boiling Point • Copyright 2019 • FLEX WordPress Theme by SNOLog in

Psalms and slow singing soften a day of broken hearts after Pittsburgh shooting